Roof Replacement guide
Two policies can pay very different amounts on the same damaged roof. The difference is depreciation, roof payment schedules, and one clause worth finding in your policy before a storm finds it for you.
Last updated: November 21, 2026
Replacement cost coverage pays what it takes to replace the damaged roof with a comparable new one, usually in two steps: an initial payment, with the withheld depreciation released after the work is done and documented. Actual cash value coverage pays the depreciated value of the roof that was damaged: its age and condition priced in, and no second step.
On a young roof the two numbers live near each other. On a 17 year old roof they can be a roof apart, because 17 years of depreciation is most of the roof.
Many carriers now attach a roof payment schedule to the policy: a table that pays a shrinking percentage of replacement as the roof ages, whatever the claim. A schedule paying 100 percent in the early years might pay half or less deep into the second decade. The schedule in your policy, if you have one, is the real math of your coverage, and it is worth reading before you need it.
This is the machinery behind the roof age letters Delaware homeowners are receiving: as the schedule shrinks, the carrier's exposure shrinks, and the homeowner's share of the next roof quietly grows.
Find three things: whether roof coverage is replacement cost or actual cash value, whether a roof payment schedule or a roof age endorsement is attached, and whether depreciation is described as recoverable, meaning it is released after documented completion, or non-recoverable. Your agent can point to each in minutes, and knowing them in a calm week beats learning them in a claim week.
However yours reads, the strongest position is the same: a documented roof, with dated photos and an inspection record, so the roof's age and condition are established facts instead of assumptions in a file.
Often, at renewal, sometimes with a roof inspection or a newer roof as the condition. That is an agent conversation, and it goes best with documentation of the roof's age and condition in hand.
The carrier withholds part of the payment as depreciation and releases it when the replacement work is complete and documented. Miss the documentation or the deadline in the policy, and the withheld part can stay withheld.
No. We document roofs and write estimates. Your agent and your policy are the authorities on your coverage, and this guide exists so you know which questions to bring them.
You started an inspection request.
Pick up where you left off. Your answers are saved on this device.